Reputation, thanks, both or nothing?

[Carbon]

WJ should have these 3 buttons

 

[Daniel]

WJ should have these 3 buttons

I think you mean facebook.

 

[DEViANCE]

Just the thanks system I think unless its possible to set the old rep system so only good rep can be given.

 

[xtremeuploader]

thanks ftw

 

[Dean2k]

Thanks, It's easy and viewable.

 

[flex202]

Just keep the "thanks",nothing else...

 

[Myth?]

Personally I think Thanks would be the best, because It actually shows that the user is helpful. So we should keep Thanks only and get rid of Reputation but clean up the postbit.

 

[Daniel]

Personally I think Thanks would be the best, because It actually shows that the user is helpful. So we should keep Thanks only and get rid of Reputation but clean up the postbit.

The postbit is on the list of things to be fixed.

 

[kundurocks]

I say both mate.

 

[DOPE]

IMO it should be setup so that when you click thank, it gives rep.

 

[hatem20]

Thanks - It tells you who exactly gave you "Thank you".

 

[StyXoN]

I'm going with the Thanks button

 

[CuraHack]

I believe the Thanks and the reputation system should work together, it's stupid to have 2 separate reputation systems in use, merge them together, that would be great!

 

[Anthonis]

Thanks is good, but reputation is needed too.
Lets leave thanks mod (only please make it expandable, that we would need to scroll half page of thank you)
Rep shows is person trusted.

 

[Daniel]

It is very clear that the last modification was a good step.

 

[MrOSX]

Nothing, it takes a hell of a long time to even get some reputation and hardly anyone shares it so i don't think we should keep it.

 

[g2znovat]

Reputation is better than Thanks Button

 

[M.D.House]

Amazing! I Like it! And i don't get the point for leaving the old reputation system.

You can make new reputation system... This thanks and Reputation Power.

Reputation Power can be equal to:

1 to 100 thanks = Reputation Power = 1 (Young Helper/Friend of board/Respected/)

101 to 200 thanks = Reputation Power = 2 (Helper/Friend of board/Respected/)

201 to 300 thanks = Reputation Power = 3 (Helper/Friend of board/Respected/)

301 to 500 thanks = Reputation Power = 4 (Forum Doctor ;D/Forum Emergency/VIP)

501 to 1000 thanks = Reputation Power 5 = (Forum Guru)

It's just an Example, guys... But I like it!

I think that some kind of ranking will make this "Thanks System" more fun.

 

[bxflow]

the thanks list can get annoying if a lot of users in a single thread get "thanks" as it would have the list almost under every post

 

[lig}{tning]

I like both of them